Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Obama's "Ghetto Speech" to our Children

When I first learned that Obama would be addressing our schools I was concerned he might try to use the opportunity to feed his liberal rubbish to my kids. I felt a sense of relief when I heard that would not really be the case. Interestingly enough, neither of my kids were shown the speech yesterday anyway (and I have kids in elementary, middle school, and high school). However, I read the text of the speech and was honestly flabbergasted by the negativity it contained, and a perspective revealed by Obama that America’s youth is some impoverished at-risk mass of depressed and misunderstood children teetering on the brink of dropping out. Mind you, this speech was for viewing by kindergartners as well! I have a daughter who just started first grade, and trust me when I say that she has no concept that a child can “drop out” of school.

Here are some of the depressing remarks with which our president defiled our nation’s youth:

“making sure you stay on track”
“turning around schools that aren’t working”
“unless you show up to those schools”
“you can’t just drop out of school and just drop in to a good job”
“if you quit on school – you are just quitting on yourself”
“I know you have a lot of challenges in your lives right now… that can make it hard to focus on schoolwork… my father left when I was two years old”
“I did some things I am not proud of and got in more trouble than I should have”
“I got a lot of second chances”
“maybe you don’t have adults in your life who give you the support you need”
“maybe you live in a neighborhood where you don’t feel safe”
“that’s no excuse for neglecting your homework or having a bad attitude,”
“that’s no excuse for talking back to your teacher, or cutting class, or dropping out of school”
“that’s no excuse for not trying”
“even when bouncing from foster home to foster home”
“keep young people out of gangs”
“your goal can be something as simple as doing all your homework”
“success through rapping or basketball”
“you can’t let failures define you”
“if you get a bad grade, that doesn’t mean you are stupid”
“even when you’re struggling…discouraged”
“and you feel like other people have given up on you”
“working hard to fix up your classroom and get you the books… you need”

Just WHO did Obama think he was talking to??? He provided a few anecdotal stories of struggle of three children: Jazmin, Andoni, and Shantell. What about Michael, Lisa, and David? This school speech is just another incident that portrays the narrow agenda of Obama at the expense of everyone else. There is a broad spectrum of experience in America that Obama either fails to recognize or chooses to ignore. Is he trying to depress our kids?

Where were comments about how the strength and future of our nation depend upon on youth? Where was the pride shown – perhaps that American children are some of the most talented and educated children in the world? Where was the “keep up the good work?” Why not “work even harder than you already are to even become greater than we expect?” Instead we got “don’t drop out” and “don’t quit on yourself” and a few patronizing attempts at optimism along the lines of “maybe you’ll be even good enough to write a book” one day.

What I thought would be perhaps the most “non-story” story of Obama’s administration so far has turned into one of the most troubling for me. Obama is either narrower in policy agenda than I had thought or perhaps more sinister in achieving what so many are afraid of – dumbing down our nation to allow for a more controlling government. You know, don’t worry, big Nanny government is here for you. Oh you poor depressed lamb, have a Wellbutrin on Uncle Sam!

2 comments:

  1. I have suburban kids also and the schools decided not to show the Obama talk.

    Obviously, his remarks were aimed at struggling urban kids. There are many schools in HISD (Houston) where far less than 50% of 9th graders will graduate, that, I am sure, is true in all of our major cities, and you can imagine that most drop-outs will be net drains on our society for all kinds of reasons.

    You or I could go to those schools and deliver the message of goals, work, education, deferral of immediate gratification, self-sufficiency, responsibility, and career; however we'd just be another white guy telling them how to live and they'd tune us out. Obama, however, they will listen to.

    So, while I have all kinds of problems with Obama's socialist agenda, I believe his message to these kids is right on. And my guess is, only the most urban school districts were showing it anyway.

    I agree with you, however, that a little bit of pride in America's greatness would have been nice. But you can't expect Obama to have any of that, since he doesn't believe our history is one of greatness.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting comment and thank you. I just wonder if Obama's message to the wrong kids could backfire. To certain schools, I might applaud his speech - but to American youth as a whole? Yuk.
    All the best,
    Your Host

    ReplyDelete

About Me

I am a typical 40-something American. I am a husband and a father. And like many of you I work hard to try to improve my life and the lives of my children. I don't want much from anyone or from my government - I just want to be left alone to go about my business and leave my little footprint on the world. I have grown very concerned about the direction our country is headed and firmly believe we have collectively lost sight of the basic principles that gave rise to our great nation. For awhile now I have been feeling more and more compelled to find a way to voice my concerns about this and share them with others - and that is the reason for this blog. I live near and work in New York City, by way of Texas, where I spent the majority of my formative years. I have an undergraduate degree in Economics and a Masters in Business Administration. My wife and I have three children, a dog, and a cat to keep us busy. I hope you enjoy what I have to say!
Politics blogs